lfbno7's tags:
There aren't a lot of jiu jitsu black belts, compared to karate black belts, because karate schools churn out black belts quickly and they are generally about 10 years old. A jiu jitsu black belt has been working at it for 10 years, is not a child, and is extremely expert.

What is jiu jitsu, you say? It is a lot like sex. You roll around on the floor with someone, close enough to kiss, close enough to get pregnant, and you play dominance submission games.

Oh and one more thing, as introduction. A jiu jitsu black belt can beat the snot out of a karate black belt.

So I was watching a rare contest, two professional fighters, and both of them were genuine jiu jitsu black belts. Usually a professional fighter is bragging that he is a jiu jitsu purple belt or something. And this particular contest was to decide a WEC world middleweight championship, in a weight class that had no champion at the time. The WEC had invited these two guys to compete for their world championship.

The underdog was from Canada. His name, Joe "Dirt" Doerksen. He's been around, I knew the name. The favorite was from Brazil, home of Gracie Jiu Jitsu (now called Brazilian Jiu Jitsu). He was more of a newcomer to MMA, but a very heralded one, having won national jiu jitsu championships, considered the best jiu jitsu artist in the world. His name, Paulo Filho, pronounced Pow-lo Feel-yo.

The pre-fight talk was that Filho would win because Brazilian jiu jitsu must, almost by definition, be far superior to Canadian jiu jitsu. More pre-fight talk was that if Doerksen could keep the fight on its feet he might win because he had more experience as a stand-up striker, and Filho spent his life rolling around on the mat with a gi on.

Interestingly, the whole Canadian vs. Brazilian thing turned out to be nothing. Interestingly, the highly touted Filho, the best jiu jitsu artist in the world, was unable to win himself an advantage on the ground. Doerksen had an answer for everything he did.

Also, Doerksen's supposed advantage in striking turned out to be nothing. The fight was soon won by Filho by giving up on the whole jiu jitsu game and just punching the crap out of Doerksen. Sort of like if pitcher Roger Clemens won a game by hitting a homerun.

I found it interesting that every single word of pre-fight analysis and argument turned out to be meaningless, how the two black belts nullified each other, there was no national supremacy, and while the favorite did eventually win, he did it in such a way that all the analysts looked like dopes.

del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • uniquely-ironic said on Nov 21, 2007....
    If properly trained it would have looked like a boring fight from the outside.  If both fighters know the submission arts and their counters it would logically be a fight of nullification.  I'd love to see it though and see their technique.
  • wakingharmony said on Nov 26, 2007....
    My littles brother has black belt in jiu jitsu and ti quando? (Sp? and if you said karate he looked a bit irritated and would correct you..he almost went to jail for hurting someone badly but it was ruled as a complete self defense and the guy would not stop..... my son-in-law is also in martial arts i he has black belt too and made colleen take at least a self defense course. He also does a thing with swords some viking thing or something..
  • lfbno7 said on Nov 26, 2007....
    Tae kwon do is a style of karate. Its practitioners think it is a separate art but it is not. The ancient Korean fighting art of tae kwon do was completely lost to history and nobody on earth remembers how to do it. Today's tae kwon do is simply one of the styles of karate, like shotokan, wadoryu, kyokushinkai and the rest. It had its beginning with Gichin Funakoshi in the late 19th century like all the other styles of karate, and its techniques can be found in Gichin Funakoshi's books.

    I never took a lesson in tae kwon do but if I walked into one of their classes I could fit right in, just watch what they're doing and do it too. All the styles of karate are similar enough that anyone who studied any of them could manage to do any of the others pretty well right off the bat.

    On the other hand, your little brother could walk into any karate school in the country and fit right in, knowing all the stuff they are doing, with very little exception. Each school has little minor variations, but your little brother could step into any karate school in the country and kick ass in it because he already knows the majority of what they're teaching.

Comment on "Jiu Jitsu black belt war"

MMA (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)