Moelt reads (4):
Who's reading Moelt (3):
JK Rowling has stated that she has always felt Dumbledore was gay. I wonder why. I never got that feeling the entire time I read the books. Now please don't think that I'm trying to downtrod gays. I don't believe gays are inferior. But it never once occured to me that Dumbledore was gay. My reasons are thus:
 
It was obvious that Dumbledore thought highly of Harry but that could have been because of who Harry was. Dumbledore could have been infatuated with him because he recognized, being the genius that he was, Harry's potential. And he recognized that because of the encounter Harry already had with Voldemort. Everyone was infatuated with Harry because of that. So why would that make Dumbledore gay?
 
Then there's the friendship with Grindewald. He was another genius with whom Dumbledore could relate. Finally, there was someone with whom Dumbledore could talk about all his ideas. So why wouldn't he latch onto him? It's not every day a genius runs into another.
 
So unless I missed something, I didn't see anything in the books that gave me any indication that Dumbledore was gay. So what do you think, folks? Did I miss something? I'd love to hear your viewpoints.


del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • silverwhisper said on Oct 24, 2007....
    me personally, i thought there was something missing from what we learn about the dumbledore/grindelwald relationship in book 7, so this new information just makes it all fit together better, if you ask me.

    [shrugs]

    i agree there isn't much information that would lead a reader to believe that in the previous books, though.

    btw: welcome to this side of soulcast, moelt! :>

    ed
  • Moelt said on Oct 24, 2007....
    Thanks, S.  :)  But for the life of me, I still can't see where there's any indication that Dumbledore is gay.  Maybe I'm in denial. Do you think?  :)
  • silverwhisper said on Oct 24, 2007....
    not everyone reads the same things the same way, you know?

    ed
  • Moelt said on Oct 24, 2007....
    Okay.  :)  I'll accept that. But a thought has occured to me just a moment ago. Do you think JK said that just to bolster more sales? Maybe get some of the people who haven't previously bought any of her books to buy some now? There are all those charities she's wanting to give money to.
  • silverwhisper said on Oct 24, 2007....
    if anything, i think that it would hurt sales to say this. stupid homophobes will, i'm quite sure, jump all over this.

    ed

Comment on "Is Dumbledore gay?"

harry potter Dumbledore magic (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)
Comment Anonymously