sheissilent's tags:
sheissilent reads (4):
I am tossing this around... and I still can't decide. Let me explain the problem, it is kind of a weird situation, so bear with me.
 
When I was 21, I engaged in a series of one night stands. I became pregnant by Dave-a man I didn't love-, and to be honest didn't even really like... but hey he was cute and I was.... well, 21.
 
It turned out it was the best thing that ever happened to me. As you know my kids are the most important thing in the world to me. My son was born, and I was a MOTHER. Everything was second to him. His father and I maintained a civil relationship for my son's sake. My son was perfect and wonderful and just what I needed. My life had direction and focus and I was very happy.
 
I met Sam, and got married. I found out I was pregnant. At the same time, Dave informed me that he had gotten some woman pregnant (he was still on the one night stand thing). When I was about 6 months pregnant, this woman gave birth to Dave's son. I never saw her or met her, but apparently she was a real loser. I heard she did drugs when she was pregnant, and had been in jail several times. Anyway, one day Dave calls me and says that the police called him, they were taking her to jail and he needed to come get his baby or they would take him to foster care. Dave works rotating shifts and wanted to know if I could keep the baby that day while he figured out what to do.
 
I reluctantly did. You see, I was selfish and I didn't want this baby around me or my husband and our family. I wanted as little as possible to do with Dave. I was trying to clean up and become a good person, and he was a reminder of my wilder, dumber days. But this was an innocent baby, and there was no way I couldn't take care of him. So at the age of 2 months, I met my son's baby brother, Luke.
 
Time went by, I saw Luke when Dave would come to pick up my son. His mother ended up going to prison, and Dave got full custody of Luke. When Luke was about 2, he noticed that my son and my new daughter called me mommy. He walked up to me, and said "I want a mommy too. You are my mommy too!"
 
Well, my  heart was in my throat, but I held him and told him I would be his mommy too. I fell in love with him at that moment. From that time on, I have been his mom. He is treated exactly like my other kids. He has his own room at my house, Dave and I share custody (although not legally), he calls my children his brother and sisters (I had another daughter 4 years ago), we list my house as his primary residence. I take him to all his doctor appointments, I take care of him when he is sick, I spank him when he is naughty. I honestly love him just as much as the other three. We have just incorporated him into our lives the same as the others.
 
He doesn't know I am not his real mom. He has no idea there is some other woman out there. He just turned 10. When should I tell him? I don't want to upset him. I want him to feel safe and secure and to know that it doesn't matter to me that he started out a little differently from the other three. But I also don't want him to grow up and be angry that I kept it from him. He has a right to know, even though it makes me ill that she might try to come back into his life when she hasn't once called or written in 10 years to see if he is okay.
 
When do I tell him? How do I tell him? How do I make sure that he knows that no matter what, I will always be his mom? It gives me nightmares sometimes, thinking about the ways this could turn out. I just want to do what's right for him.
 
Any thoughts?


del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • beyondtheveil said on Feb 17, 2007....
    sheissilent- I think this should have been talked about starting around the age of five or six. There is a very good possibility the biological mother will enter his life at some point, and the older he becomes, the angrier he will become for not being told.
     
    But this is an opinion from one person, who could be wrong. I hope you get more comments from others so you can weigh this question from several viewpoints. I would not seriously consider any action until you receive a consensus from both here and elsewhere.
  • momsrock said on Feb 17, 2007....
    My husband is not my son's biological father but has been with him since he was two and we married when he was three. We just had the conversation a couple of months ago...when he was 6.  We dreaded the conversation for so long but it was more of a relief for my son. He had a lot of questions but he was not upset.
     
    I think it will be harder the longer you wait....and the older he gets the more upset he will be as beyondtheveil said. I believe the most important part of the conversation is stressing that you are his mother because you loved him not because there wasn't anyone else to do it. Telling him that you are the lucky one that had the opportunity to be his mother and how happy that has made you is important. It's going to be confusing to him and change everything he has ever believed and he needs to be reassured that it was because you loved him and not because his mother is/was in jail. But, it is a conversation I would have with him now...before he gets any older.
  • gingersoul said on Feb 17, 2007....

    She......i totally agree with beyond and moms...the longer you wait the harder will be for your son to understand the reason of your long silence.

    Plus, telling him soon will give him the time to develop the rigth emotional reaction in case his natural mother would ever show up in his life. We always must be ready for the worst so that we have all the bases covered. I would suggest to set a special time with him,  a day only for you two guys together.

    Let him konw you love him exactly like the other siblings even though he came into your life in a different way. But even if the circumnstances have been different the love that grew for him is the same love you have for your other kids. His father is going to play an important role in this explanation as well. maybe you two should talk with him together.

    Then you will need to gently deliver the new to his siblings.....

    But i really think you should do you it now. Waiting is not bringing anything good.

    Good luck..its a tough moment to face for your family.

    Are you strong enough to face the emotional turmoil?...{{hugs}}

  • MissMimi said on Feb 17, 2007....
    sis, I hope you tell him right away. It would be a terrible shock if this woman suddenly shows up wanting to be mommy. I think you and the dad should do it together, and be sure to stress that you love him very very much and you always did. That's the most important thing. You might also consider consulting an attorney so that you have some legal standing in this situation, just in case she does show up.
    And, may I just say... I think you are an incredibly loving woman. You did good, kiddo.
  • pickersplock said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I agree with all of the above. Tell him, it's not like you're going to stop being
    his mom. You are his mom. She's his birth mother but she hasn't nurtured and
    cared for him like you have. Kids are remarkably resiliant and you will probably
    find that after the conversation he will say, "okay", and then ask for a sandwich.
  • secretlife said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I am in agreement that this should have been talked about from the earliest days.
    I also agree that you and his dad should talk about this with him together and i think the two of you should talk together first before you go to him.
     
    of course you should tell him that this one fact doesn't change the way you feel about him at all, and that you love him the same as you love your biological children....and that nothing will change that.
     
    secrets like this can only hurt kids later on and cause them to mistrust the people who they should trust most.  so that's why it's really important to do this soon.
     
    you are a loving woman.  i know you will find the words.
  • minniemouse said on Feb 17, 2007....

    There are all kinds of books out there written for kids about adoption that will help explain the situation and also for you to help him with his emotions.  It sounds like you haven't officially adopted him, but you have adopted him in your heart, so the situation still applies.  Believe it or not, Jamie Lee Curtis (yes the actress) wrote a book for kids about this and my friend used it in a similar situation. 

    Good luck......I wish there were more people in this world that are capable of opening their heart to a child that needs a parent. 

  • kruuyai said on Feb 17, 2007....
    well, I'm not a parent, but my gut reaction when I read your post was that it would be better not to tell him unless he asks about it... because it seems like he has always known on some level.  Also, I felt like he was too young to be told news like that now... that it could be too devastating and might be easier to handle in his teens or even later... but all the parents had just the opposite opinion, so I don't know how much this is worth.  The main thing I wanted to say was that I was really impressed and touched by the love you showed this little boy by taking him into your heart.  Whenever you tell him, I think it's important that you make sure he understands that he'll always have that love from you, no matter what... I think that would be the biggest fear for a kid on hearing that his mom isn't his mom... you know, like why is she telling me this *now*?  There must be some reason.  I think that's likely to be going through his head, so you'll want to set it up before you tell him, so he knows where you're coming from.
  • mobil said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I agree with the majority above, I think all three adults should sit down and
    agree to agree on how this is handled and what will be said before talking
    to him.
     
    Most likely he will seek out his biological mother at some point in his life. The
    only way I've seen something like this go badly is when the child or
    children weren't told.
  • babyboomerang said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I haven't much to add to what everyone else has already said, except
    perhaps to advise that you not say that you are not
    his real mom. You are his mom in every sense of the word. Tell him that
    while someone else gave birth to him & she was unable to care for
    him, he is a part of your family forever and you will always be his
    mother. Tell him there are lots of families that started like his, and
    in all sorts of other different ways; but family is family, and family
    sticks together always.

    Yes, you should tell him as soon as possible. Since you seem to have a
    good relationship with his natural father, include his dad in the
    conversation. Have a good talk with his dad first so that you are both
    in agreement as to how you will proceed.

    Be prepared, too, for some regression & misbehavior on his part
    once he knows. He's likely to be angry and take it out on you...see
    just how far he can push you before you push him away (which you, of
    course, will not do). Give him a bit of leeway, but try to keep
    disciplining him as usual. Be prepared for the dreaded words:
    You're not my real mother, you can't tell me what to
    do!
    and prepare your gentle but firm response to that. Try
    not to feel hurt by it; he will be hurting worse inside.

    Finally, sheissilent, give yourself the credit you deserve for doing
    something many other women would be unable or unwilling to do. You're
    an amazing mom, and don't forget it.
  • justlittleme said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I believe you should be honest with him.The sooner the better.He is still very young and it is a lot easier growing up knowing then not knowing.He will respect you for being honest then keeping it from him.I know I was raised by my step father.As far as I knew he was my daddy.One day a strange man showed up and he was my father.I can not express to you the pain that it caused me as a 8 year old little girl.I hated my mother and my father for many years.It might be hard for him to understand at first but in the long run he will be grateful to you.You have to respect children for them to respect you.And anyone can be a father or a mother but it takes a special person to be a mommy or a daddy..................................best luck to you..............
  • boyzmom said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I just want to add that it shouldn't come across to him that you do not want him to know his biological mother. He may look for her because he will rebel against you or like an adopted friend of mine, he may be so concerned for your feelings that he will choose not to learn who his biological mother is and make you feel guilty. You know his personality and will probably deal with it just as a mother should!
  • missunderstood1162 said on Feb 17, 2007....

    I think you are an amazingly unconditionally loving mother on all levels.  I totally admire you for embracing this tiny boy and calling him your own.  What a totally unselfish thing to do. 

    How much do you currently talk with any of your children now about really important "big stuff"?  like grown up decisions, sex, unanswered questions, money, feelings, etc?  I ask this because I was always very very upfront with my boys about all sorts of things as they were growing up. {from little bitty on up} They were not shocked by some of the realities of life because I explained things to them.  The reason that I did this is because I feel like my parents shielded me from a lot of the realities of life and when I found them out ---as a very naive 19 year old girl ---I was devastated by many of my discoveries.

    I wished my parents would have told me more about sex.  That my mom had sat down and been frank with me about intimacy and sexual pleasure.  I wish they would have told me how hard it was being a grown up.  How difficult it was to make ends meet.  You name it.  I felt really cheated out of this information.  Perhaps I could have made stronger decisions if I had known the realities. 

    So I vowed to be as honest as I could with my boys (on their level) without overwhelming them.  I didn't OVER GIVE information either.  and finally I surrounded them with a soft place to fall with their fears (if any) and concerns and if they wanted to talk.  (one of the two always wanted to) 

    How emotionally mature is he?

    I only have this to base my reply on hon.  I think you are so amazing.  Follow your heart and think of all the things that "could" happen and how you would feel if you were him.  Then proceed.  Bless you.

    {{{{hugs}}}}}

    Lisa

    (yes that really is my name)

  • mom said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I feel that his father should tell him.  If you do tell him, I think you should explain it in a way that might be loving. I would explain that sometimes there are 2 mommies, and that he is loved by his moms and his dad.  I wish you the best.  It is a difficult thing.
  • Jenna said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I will just put my 2 cents in here....I agree with most...the sooner you tell him the better.....
     
    So many people have given you wise advice on how to do it.  He needs to know... there may be a storm to go through....but do it now...so in his teenage years... he can get things figured out. 
     
    How wonderful of your heart.... to be his mom...he will always see you as that. 
    I admire you compassion and love for a child who needed you!
    You are indeed his mom. 
  • denman said on Feb 17, 2007....
    i was adopted. i'm now 46. i found out when i was 17. met my blood mother, and the mom that raised me will always be mom. i am currently friends with my blood mother.there is no right time, you'll know when the time is right for all. my mom that raised me passed away 1 year ago. gina my blood mom was there for me. don't rush anything. denman blog. all the best and take care
  • MsBradford07 said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I think that Dave and you should sit and discuss how you can tell this boy about his mother without him hating you and his real mother. Let him know that you and his father and everyone else will be there for him.  
  • LadyGamer said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I saw a cartoon once that I loved. I took it home to my ADOPTED baby brother.
     
    Family Circus: Dolly says to Jeffy "That is Timmy. He's adopted. That means where WE came from Mommy's belly, HE came from his Mommy's heart."
     
    My little brother is actually the son of my older sister. When she was seventeen she became pregnant from a one night stand. She had no desire to keep the baby so before his birth, our parents adopted him. They preferred to keep their grandchild safe at home as their own than always wonder.
    He is now the most incredible eighteen year old boy you can imagine with an amazing future in store for him.
    When he was nine our aunt make a callous remark in his hearing about the adoption.  Mother was forced to explain things to him then. He took it very well. Just another part of his life, okay Mom, I love you too, can I have an iceepop?
     
    I think now is a good age to introduce this to him.
  • RollingC said on Feb 17, 2007....
    I've read some of the comments but then skipped the rest to give my unbiased two cents worth......
    If you haven't told him already(and you should've done it at an early age) you should wait until he's mature enough to handle it and by all means all the adults should be on the same page when you tell him.....good luck and I think that his love for you won't let anything interfere with anything...
  • yani said on Feb 18, 2007....

    You should tell him as soon as you have agreed with Dave how you two are doing it. Above all else, make it very clear to him that you are telling this to him now because you think it's the best time, not because he's done something wrong or anything like that. Assure him that this bit of information will not change anything between you two, that the love you have for him for always, always be the same. I know that you can do this for you are great mother. You truly are :)

    Good luck and Gob bless

  • sheissilent said on Feb 18, 2007....
    Thank you everyone for the advice and comments. It helps so much to have unbiased opinions.
     
    Please believe me when I say that I am the lucky one, not Luke. After so many things I have screwed up in my life, for God to give me such a wonderful little boy to love still amazes me. He keeps blessing me even when I don't deserve it.  I am just so grateful that I get to be part of his life.
     
    Dave and I did go to a lawyer last year. My greatest fear is that something will happen to Dave and that 1) Luke's "mom" (how I hate to say that) will come back and try to take him, or that 2) he would be put in foster care because I have no legal rights to him. The lawyer said the best we can do is for Dave to put it in his will that he wants Luke to go to me if something did happen. He said since Dave and I were never married, it would be nearly impossible for me to either adopt him or even get some kind of legal guardianship for him. 
     
    Luke is 10, but not a very mature 10. I honestly don't know how he would react if I told him. I have brought this up to Dave and he doesn't want to tell him, but Dave never wants to do anything that requires effort. I think he should be told, for the reasons so many of you have stated, and the fact that when all is said and done, he needs to know that he can still trust his mom and my love for him.
     
    I will let you know what happens. I just want to do what is best for Luke.
    Thanks again.
  • kruuyai said on Feb 18, 2007....

    I was reading through some of the other comments, and one of them gave me an idea.  babyboomerang said:

    "Tell him that while someone else gave birth to him & she was unable to care for
    him, he is a part of your family forever and you will always be his
    mother." 

    How about telling him when you're explaining about the birds and the bees?  It would be really natural to talk about how babies are born and how they usually live with the woman who birthed them, but sometimes she isn't able to take care of her baby so another loving woman takes the baby into her home and raises him.  Something along those lines.  You know kids better than I do, so I realize my wording sucks, but it just struck me that that would be a very easy and natural way to bring it up.

  • evillinclinations said on Feb 20, 2007....
    I have a little bit of input on this one. Everyone I've known who was adopted (in whatever way) has told me that they found out when they were 12, 13, 14, 16....and that it made their teenage years that much harder, and they wish they'd known sooner, so they could have dealt with it before the insanity of adolescence.
  • Alyss said on Apr 03, 2007....
    Somewhat belatedly ,I don't think there is ever a perfect time to share the news it's one of those things best shared from the outset but now it's a case of sooner is better than later.

    I would suggest sitting him down and sharing his history, as much of it as he is emotionally able to cope with, as matter of factly as you can. There is no way of predicting how he will react to the news but the longer it is left the more likely it could feel like he has been lied to but that's just my opinion.

Comment on "I would like an opinion please- especially from you parents."

parenting children parent Agree Decisions mom (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)
Comment Anonymously

No "Bah, Humbug" here! I sent scrooge packing a long time ago....
Today was full....
I was honest that Santa Claus does not exist. So 12yrold,10yrold,and 5yrold are aware who is really spending the money and buying the presents. So what do your kids beleive? How old were you or your kids when the illusion of Santa was lifted?...
questioning people and how selfish they are when it comes to break ups, involving kids...
of parenting...

Subscribe to the SoulCast Newsletter To Receive the Best Uncensored Blogs About Love, Sex, Relationships, God, Politics, and More.


Ever wonder what people really think and how they really live?

Read about the real lives of regular people like you whose powerful moving blogs will make you smile, cry, emotional, and warm inside.

Your FREE SoulCast newsletter is just moments away. Receive your first feel-good blog by entering your email address below.

First Name:
Your Email:


You can unsubscribe at any time with one click. We NEVER sell or share your email address with anyone. Period. close