None of my blogs are researched in depth. Any ideas I express here come from a single source of inspiration and are backed only with knowledge I have stored away in memory. I don’t really feel like taking the time to write a proper essay and I am not trying to change the views of the world or even sway them. I just write to share an idea and hope that it might give a few people something to think about. The researchers here on SoulCast are people like TheNakedProfessor and StupidGenius, who present there ideas with a lot of data, presumably from a variety of sources.
Not me.
So, that brings me to today’s topic:
feces (in your face bold type). Well, not exactly feces but how and possibly why it figures so largely in our language. The other day I was following some comments on Hunter’s posting about
The Aquatic Ape Theory and I noticed a comment by lidstrom82 that said, “I wonder if that doesn't rob all humanity of its strongest and greatest gifts, if we simply see ourselves as an extension of animals that fling their own poop and pick each other for fleas.” Immediately I recalled something I had read a few years ago in Carl Sagan’s book,
The Dragons of Eden, a book about the evolution of intelligence, concerning human language similarities with the behaviourisms of other primates.
Sadly, when apes and humans are referred to as being evolutionary relatives, some people immediately conjure up images such as the ones lidstrom82 mentioned. I don’t mean to say lidstrom82 is an ape-hater or that he looks down on apes. But when we think about apes flinging their feces we think them dirty and look at our clean hands and say, “How could we be related to such a creature?” Well, this post is not out to prove that we are related to apes (though we share 98.4% of the same genes with chimps) but how pooh-chucking is alive and well in human society.
Duck!
It is sometimes said that the only thing that separates us from the animals is the thin skin of civilization. Take away that and our lives would resemble that of many animals. (In the
Dune prequel series,
The Butlerian Jihad a robot keeps “feral humans” in cages to conduct experiments on them in order to study human behaviour. Stripped of clothes and culture and introduced to a society of no formal language, the humans in these cages are no better than monkeys in an over-crowded zoo.) Conversely some animals such as wolves and some birds and insects form complex hierarchical societies. Some primates live in troupes with a clan or tribe-like hierarchy. There are many comparisons that can be made.
One point that is always mentioned is that humans have evolved a complex language system of communication. Language is what helps us record, either mentally or extra-somatically, information about our environment, our past, our future plans, etc. Languages have a complex array of tenses to refer to things past, present and future, as well as things that happened before other things in the past, things that were expected to happen in the past but didn’t, things that are expected to happen in the future, hypothetical situations and so on. It is our ability to use language that has been the cornerstone of our rise to civilization. Therefore, it should be no surprise that some of our animal behaviourisms have been supplanted by the use of words over actions.
So, let’s get back to scooping up a handful of crap and throwing it at someone who has pissed us off (urine reference). The English language has steaming piles of phrases and expressions that replace actually laying our hands on our excrement by putting our tongues into action instead. Consider the following expressions and the situations in which they are used and then replace each image with how it might seem if we were referring to actual fecal matter in a way that is familiar to apes.
“Oh, shit!” – When something goes wrong. Life has just hit you with a load of feces.
“Holy shit!” – Something very surprising is happening or has just happened. It’s as awesome, or as awful, as encountering…
“I had a shitty day.” – Things went very poorly today. (Some apes wouldn’t stop throwing the stuff at me.)
“Eat shit!” – The basic message apes send when they throw the stuff.
“This tastes (smells) like shit!” – Who really knows how it tastes? Maybe it’s an ape reference. Surely some of them get hit in the mouth.
“You little shit!” – Small, irritating piece of crap that has flung itself into your life.
“He thinks he’s the big shit around here.” – The guy who gets everyone jumping for fear of what will happen if the big shit comes at them. Or perhaps the guy with the biggest load to throw!
“The shit hit the fan.” – Forget throwing the stuff. Why not let it fly everywhere?
“I’m up shit creek.” – We’ve outdone the apes with that one. It’s not just flying but flowing big enough to form a creek!
“Shit disturber.” – Someone who begins to pick up feces and prepares to throw it around, upsetting everybody.
That’s just ten. There are plenty more. As you can see, we are not so clean when it comes to throwing feces. We just do it with language instead of words. And thankfully so! They say actions speak louder than words, and that is one level of volume I am glad we don’t reach. It’s not just English either. Any language I have encountered has words for feces that are used when things turn shitty. In Danish you can call someone a cow shit. In French you say shit when things go wrong. In Japanese you can call someone a shit-dripper. In German you can call someone a shitter. Not surprisingly, when some chimps and gorillas have been taught to use sign language to communicate with humans, they have learned to create insult words using fecal references. For example, one researcher was called a “green shit” in sign language when his chimp was upset with him.
Incidentally, there was a
South Park episode about being able to say shit on TV. The story revealed that shit was originally a curse word and that curse words were meant not to be used because, in effect by using them, you were cursing people literally. Viewed in this light, throwing feces at someone might indeed curse them if they become ill from
e coli or other bacterial infections.
It’s probably best just to let steaming poops lie.
Note: The title of this posting is also the title of an album by the band Type O-Negative.
In the future look forward to: Explanation for the Asshole