Weird_World's tags:
Weird_World reads (0):
some days back someone called me up because he was having trouble in his relationship...
not one of my favorite people, but you gotta do what you gotta do...so i gave some sort of sane advice for about an hour, and it seemingly worked...
and it left me with an interesting question...how much truth in a relationship is too much truth??
everyone tells us that relationships are totally supposed to be based on truth...yeah sure in an ideal world it should, but sadly we don't live ideal lives...at least most of us don't...and sometimes the truth is too much truth...
the person who called me up, used to be a player, and then he fell for someone...seemingly fell really bad...and now his entire past is like a big stone which can very much engulf and eat up his relationship...so he is living on half-truths and mostly lies...like how many women he dated before, or how many he slept with...yeah the chasms of relationships...
and the entire conversation took me back by half a decade when i was sadly in such a relationship...when i found out the truth, it was hard to trust again...i met this guy, and kinda fell for him, or whatever it was...he told me that he had a non-existent past, lesser than mine, made me ashamed of my almost non-existent past...one and a half years down the line, when he thought i was two-timing him (which i wasn't, we had broken up, and after some months i started dating someone else, and in no world would that be considered two-timing) he told me that he was a real player, i was his 26th girl-friend...from 2nd or 3rd to 26th seriously felt like a kick, and not in the good sense...and when i asked him why he waited for one and a half years to enlighten me, he told me that i would have never given him the time of the day had i known in the beginning...i guess he was bartering forgiveness for my supposed infidelity...i did forgive him i guess...but it was never the same...somewhere the trust was dead and the insecurities came to live...even though we trudged along for half and year more, i could never trust him again...something over i guess is something over, and trust was that something over for us...
so on the phone with the person asking me for advice i told him one simple thing...keep track of your lies if you are not planning to tell the truth ever...and gave my example...

so how much truth is too much truth?? should relationships be based on truth, or half-lies...in the end we are all lost in the questions...and sometimes when we have too much to lose we probably turn to the lies and half-lies...but in the end, is it really worth it??...making ourselves acceptable with lies is really worth it??


del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • moonriver said on Jul 30, 2009....
    hi wired girl.
    i have ambivalent thoughts on this.

    first point: it isn't easy to know the whole truth about your own life and loves (and i don't mean just the number, whether it's 2 or 6 or 26), much less tell everything you know as true to someone else.

    second point: if you truly love someone, and intend to nurture that love for the long haul, you need to share with them what your heart and soul tells you. 
    always, no ifs and buts.
    as in the classic "i would have told you earlier but..."
    this means, no intentional lies and self-serving half-lies.
    for me, this point is the biggest deal-breaker.

    you have the option to keep silent on some aspects, yes.
    it's your choice, really.
    no moral judgments here.
    but if you continue to keep silent for long, then the other person will simply "fill in the blanks" in ways you can't control or predict.
    and then one day, they will simply decide you're too patchy or slippery or sneaky to be trusted.

    trust is such a fragile sprout.
    and lies are stupid morons. 
    they will always be found out no matter how hard you try to hide them.

    trust, watered by truth and love, can grow into a giant sequoia that can last a hundred lifetimes.
    and when it does, it no longer matters whether you tell this or that piece of truth or lie or not.
    the sequoia will know, and understand, and endure.

    i guess that brings me to my third point.
    which is that, ancient sequoias are hard but good to find.


  • Hegemone said on Jul 30, 2009....
    I think on things like you mentioned, the truth is incredibly important.  If she's not going to give him the time of day because of it, maybe she's just not the right girl for him anyway.  He would need somebody really understanding and if that's going to chase her away, then she's not that girl and he could be wasting his and her time.  That said, there are times that a relationship can handle a little fib. 

    I'm not going to tell my husband every detail of the hour long bitch fest with his mom I had to have in order to get her to let him use her car, but I will tell him that I spoke with her and she doesn't mind.  He doesn't need the stress of knowing I got in an argument with his mother, and there's nothing he could add to the scenario anyway.  If it comes up and he asks I'll give him full disclosure, but otherwise, it's not something that's essential.  Further, I must point out, that is sort of a 'sub-lie'.  It's not a lie in itself, really it's just omission of facts, but to me that still classifies as a lie.  Just never bringing up that you are a player when it's obvious that it can be a big deal isn't excusable.

    Lies always come out eventually.  Always.  And they bite hard when they come back too, so it's best just to leave it alone.  The only kind of outright lies I will tell are tiny fibs to cover a GOOD surprise I'm planning, and even then I tread lightly.
  • Weird_World said on Jul 30, 2009....
    hey moonriver,
    i have just spent half an hour listening to the same moron who started all these questions in my head...and this time i told him to tell the truth, if he wanted a future with the girl...a couple of hypothetical situations thrown in offcourse... ;-)
    from my cynical point of view, i happen to think that lies are very high maintenance and time consuming...
    "Oh what a tangled web we weave, when first we practise to deceive"

    WW

    P.S->Anyone can home deliver me an ancient sequoias...will do the replanting myself... :-)
  • Weird_World said on Jul 30, 2009....
    hey Hegemone,
    fibs and white lies are no big deal...we all understand them...even if we throw tantrums in the beginning...
    and considering i have been in the situation which that poor girl might end up, i can imagine what she will got through...and it isn't easy to think a relationship with the same view after the new found knowledge...and it makes you feel in the end that the considerable time spend together was based on a lie...
    and again it comes down to lies...maybe in the end a really hurting truth is better than a lie which will in most probability snowball into a mountain...

    WW

  • moonriver said on Jul 30, 2009....
    ww--
    "lies are high-maintenance and time-consuming..." i totally agree.
    ditto re ancient sequoias.
    i'll try and send you one, once i decide (on impulse) to live among the california redwoods... :-)

  • bigbluesky said on Aug 26, 2009....
    you can say that again moonriver

Comment on "Sex lies and truth..."

life relationships love Truth lie (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)
Comment Anonymously

I am a published photographer!!!! yay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
its back for more surgery I go......with a pick axe here and a hatchet there........
Could it be?

No ...

Wait ....

Not sure ...

Wait ....

Definitely yes ......
And she wants more!

This morning I took in 15 hats to the craft consignment shop. The owner loved them and put me under contract for...