So, Bush and company are out.  Good riddance.  But the story cannot end there.  The things they did while in power are not only inexcusable, but illegal as well.  Their excesses cannot just be relegated to "letting bygones be bygones."  They must be held accountable.

As pointed out by Andrew Sullivan here is a quote by Steve Benen, of The Washington Monthly:

 "The moral of this story is not the danger for Obama going forward with his Gitmo decommissioning, the moral is that when venal, shallow, small men are given unfettered power and authority, they do incompetent, stupid, and evil things."


del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • ALIENated said on Jan 25, 2009....
    
    You should listen to someone other that Andrew Sullivan and CNN. The 
    biased media has helped get our country in the mess it is in now by 
    reporting stupid stuff to try and make the Bush administration look bad. 
    Their goal was to make things look so bad, everyone would vote for 
    whichever loser the Democrats came up with, and they succeeded. We 
    now have a real loser in the White House. As Dennis Miller explains just 
    about every night, stupid liberals and the biased media have caused us 
    to lose a valuable tool in the war on terrorists. That tool would be 
    waterboarding. If that practice killed people, I would be against it myself.
    However, as Miller says, to have something like waterboarding is invaluable. 
    It will cause just about anyone to spill their guts, but there is no way it is 
    going to kill them. I just hope you, Andrew Sullivan, and the biased liberal 
    media remembers Bush when the terrorists get brave enough to try their 
    next ploy, and they will do something to test Borax. I am sure he will want
    to sit down with them and talk about it. God help us.
    
    
  • Devin23 said on Jan 26, 2009....
    Alien- You mention in a lot of your post about being a god fearing christian and that is fine, but I don't remember the christian bible saying anything about water boarding being ok?  (not that I really have a dog in this fight.)  You arguements just come off sometimes inconsistent.   It was just an observation. 
  • kelly said on Jan 26, 2009....
    Devin, alienated believes that ethical and humane behavior is something that other people should engage in.

    So, Dennis Miller believes in torture.  I guess that's no big surprise, although in the past conservatives would have been against the idea of torture.  The problem is we don't have too many conservatives anymore.  We have Republicans.  Just because some form of abuse does not actually kill someone does not mean it isn't torture.  Give me a break.
  • ALIENated said on Jan 26, 2009....
    
    I cannot speak generally for Mr. Miller. I just loosely quote what he said on
    his daily radio show. I doubt that he is for real torture, like shoving bamboo
    under fingernails or whacking off fingers. Neither am I. The point is, water-
    boarding is not in that category. The point is also that the biased media 
    made a mountain out of every molehill in order to get their boy elected, 
    which they did. So enjoy the next four years, if you survive them. 
    OhBummer is already back peddling on many issues. He is finding out the 
    real scoop. He will soon be indistinguishable from Bush (or any other
    president) soon on many issues. Certain actions require set reactions.
    That is just the way it is. When the CIA or FBI report to Borax that a
    nuclear device is set of blow in some large U.S. city, you can bet your
    bottom that OhBummer will do whatever it takes to make sure it does
    not go off. Even if that means pouring some water in some terrorist's
    face. And if that device is planted in a city near you and your family, 
    you had better hope that it works, that they get the information they 
    need as quickly as they need it. It is like what I read in a James Bond 
    book (I think it was). Sometimes the good guys have to be worse than
    the bad guys. How else will they beat them? Distasteful things happen
    in wars that the general public should not be exposed to. The biased
    media has dug all that up as if a Republican president is the only one
    who has ever had to deal with it. You can also bet your bottom that
    things worse than waterboarding have been done under every 
    president. Not because they wanted it to, but because it was
    necessary. The other side typically chops off the heads of their
    prisioners. How does that compare with a little water in their faces
    on this side of the fence?
    
    
  • kelly said on Jan 27, 2009....
    " The point is, water-
    boarding is not in that category. "

    Of course it is. The United States has prosecuted people for using this very technique in the past.  Your moral relativism is unconvincing.
  • stopmediabias said on Jan 27, 2009....

    Kelly the United States prosecuted people for torture.  Waterboarding in proper context is not torture because it doesn't rise to the level of extreme.  We waterboarding someone for just over two minutes, the people we prosecuted did a whole host of torturous things along with waterboarding to the point the victim passed out several times.

     If you guys had a single thing on Bush or Cheney you would have done it by now.  There is nothing because they didn't break the law. 

    Could it be you are scared?  Maybe a little bit of buyers remorse with the current President?  Technically Bush and Cheney are gone and we have bigger problems that you seem to have taken your eyes off of.  Now if President Obama captures a hardcore jiadist like Khalid Sheik Mohammed and he has five minutes to decide, hmmm waterboard or risk peoples lives, that's a tough one.  What do you think he will do?

  • ALIENated said on Jan 27, 2009....
    
    Stop using that idiotic ticking time bomb scenario. Some people's tiny brains
    cannot handle the truth. I love the way liberals end an arguement by calling
    your statements idiotic or calling you a Nazi. And, if you win a war, you get
    to punish the losers how ever you see fit. What do you think the Islamic
    extremists are going to do to all of us if they get the upper hand? People
    better start taking this crap serious or we will all soon be wearing rags on
    our heads and bowing to Allah. When our enemies fight honorably, we should
    certainly fight honorably. You know, the way our founders marched out to
    meet the British, the way we fought the way they did. When our enemies
    fly into buildings or blow up innocent men, women, and children, any 
    measure should be used to head that off. War has no room for bleeding
    heart liberals. The biased media outing certain aspects of war to the
    general public is like doing a reality program in a public restroom. There
    are just some things that should be kept behind closed doors. That is
    why we elect people to do our dirty work. OhBummer will do it just the
    same as Bush did it or we will all soon be slaves to Islam.
    
    
  • kelly said on Jan 31, 2009....
    "If you guys had a single thing on Bush or Cheney you would have done it by now.  There is nothing because they didn't break the law."

    With the help of John Yoo, Bush passed secret laws attempting to legitimize anything he wanted to do.  Bush certainly broke the law and the end of the story is not yet written.

    The ticking time bomb scenario IS idiotic.  It gets invoked constantly as a tactic of fear (hm, who else uses fear as a tactic?  why, that would be terrorists) when in fact there is almost never a real ticking time bomb situation.  It is an emotional argument, not a rational one.
  • stopmediabias said on Feb 02, 2009....

    The ticking time bomb is not that far fetched, Frontline's (PBS) torture site has some very interesting opinions, I wouldn't expect you to read it though.

    Kalid Sheik Mohammed was captured in the dead of night, that leaves officials with very limited amount of time to find out what he knows.  We waterboarded him, how would you have handled it?  Maybe hand him a copy of Al Gore's global warming manifesto and as him to unclench his fist and please tell us where all of his friends are?

  • kelly said on Feb 02, 2009....
    "Kalid Sheik Mohammed was captured in the dead of night, that leaves officials with very limited amount of time to find out what he knows."

    What does the time of day he was captured have to do with anything?  And what ticking time bomb did they discover by torturing him?

    "... I wouldn't expect you to read it though."

    Oh, good.  I'm limited on time anyway.
  • stopmediabias said on Feb 03, 2009....

    Kelly-If we capture someone that we know is in the midst of planning an attack and we capture them in the dead of night when no-one knows it there is a window of opportunity there.

    Lets say myself and my two friends are planning a bank heist at 9:00 in morning and I get captured at 3:00 in the morning.  When my friends discover I was captured they are going to vanish.  But if we can get names by 4:00 and get them or information about what bank it makes sense the time.

    He wasn't tortured, and virtually anything could be a ticking time bomb.  An attack in the next month on the New York City subway system could technically be called a ticking time bomb.

  • kelly said on Feb 16, 2009....
    "He wasn't tortured, and virtually anything could be a ticking time bomb.  An attack in the next month on the New York City subway system could technically be called a ticking time bomb."

    That's not the way the scenario is presented.  'Ticking time bomb' means imminent danger.  Usually within hours, as the people who are fond of invoking this highly unlikely scenario put it.

    Torture--which waterboarding is--produces unreliable information and it creates stronger, more bitter, more determined enemies.  I'm sure you're not concerned with the moral implications of torture as I am, but there are practical reasons not to torture as well.

    Your explanation of what time of day someone was captured makes no sense.
  • stopmediabias said on Feb 18, 2009....
    Once again, to broad: imminent danger fits into attacks that will kill people in a week or a month.  If you knew there was a bomb in a major city that was going to go off in the next 30 days couldn't that be considered an imminent threat?
     
    Waterboarding as performed by Americans is not torture because it doesn't rise to the level of extreme and there is no intent to commit the act of torture.  A systematic prolonged infliction of severe pain or discomfort can be put on someone with the use of waterboarding, we didn't do this.  We waterboarded this guy for just over two minutes and it lead to a number of lives being saved.
     
     
  • kelly said on Feb 20, 2009....
    That is complete nonsense.  Waterboarding isn't even the whole picture.  Americans have beaten, sometimes to death, detainees.  We are now known as a torturing nation.  Recently it was decided that the Uighur detainees were not guilty of anything (big surprise) but we told China we couldn't return them to China because they might be tortured.  China, appropriately, laughed in our face.

    Bush has completely blown it for us.  He has brought the civility of the entire world down by sullying our reputation as fair players and respecters of human rights.  He belongs in jail for war crimes.
  • ALIENated said on Feb 21, 2009....
    
    Do you honestly believe that things have happened under Bush that have not
    happened under every president, even Lincoln or FDR? You probably do. If I 
    were you I would leave this horrible country and go to China or one of those 
    other great countries out there. I hear Mexico is warm if you are not slaughtered
    by some drug ganster. Maybe somewhere in the middle east where they think 
    more like you. You do believe in whacking your wife's head off if you get tired
    of her, right? Or whacking off the heads of innocent journalists, right? I do not 
    believe in torture either, but the difference in you and me is, I believe very little
    of what the liberal media says any more. I do not believe anything that Hollywood
    says anymore. They have lost all credibility and have left impartial journalism far
    behind. People the world over recognize that now even if half the poor saps in 
    this country do not. So why should we believe any of the reports of torture that
    come from these lying bastards? You cannot lie about most of what you report 
    (especially when it comes to Democrats and Republicans) and then expect 
    anyone to believe you on something like this. I hear reports from people that 
    have inspected Gitmo and they say there is no evidence of torture. And they 
    have no track record of lying. So who do we believe? Why should we believe
    a pack of liars about anything? I have no doubts that some aggressive 
    interrogations may have taken place (you see them every day on TV as you
    root for the "good guys"), but how can we believe a pack of liars that says it
    happens all the time when we know in whom they place their allegiance? You
    cannot have your cake and eat it, too.
    
    
  • stopmediabias said on Feb 26, 2009....
    I have made the challenge numerous times to bloc and others:
     
    Show me any single piece of solid evidence that shows the United States government tortured people as a matter of policy or non-policy in the last 8 years.
     
    I became so disgusted by people like bloc who have ran our President and our military through the shit with complete falsehoods that I spent months searching and trying to substantiate the torture claim and I am yet to find real evidence. 
     
     So Kelly please feel free, take your time.  Search Google, Nexus, Yahoo, anywhere and find a substantiated case of torture that meets the legal definition, a challenge you.
     
     

Comment on "Bygones cannot be bygones"

bush torture Dick Cheney rule-of-law sorry libs (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)
Comment Anonymously

A new dinosaur named Tatankacephalus cooneyorum, was recently unearthed in Montana. For me it's not a particularly exciting find. It's a rather standard addition to the anklosaur family, a group of armored dinoraurs with club like tails. It is surmise...
Caroline Glick's interesting little ode to George W. Bush and her pain at him no longer being POTUS...
People willing to sacrifice freedom for temporary security deserve neither and will lose both....