oh lucy! such a decision i wish noone ever has to make. only you know your dog well enough to decide when the time is right. what you have to ask yourself...am i only keeping the dog around for myself at this point? if the answer is yes then it is probably time to start preparing to let her go. i'm sure you have already been preparing. it's a really awful state to be in...one that i've been in so i understand. at the shelter that i worked in i soothed and consoled soooo many lovely people that had come to make that final decision. it is never easy. the guilt of not letting them go is as bad as the guilt from letting them go. she is a beloved family member. you have to ask yourself this also...in her bravery and strength is she just being brave for you, her "person"? if she could talk...what would she say? a dog's eyes hold a lot of answers. i'm here for you and stand behind whatever decision you make. lots of love to you...fraggles...ps...i've missed you