stark's tags:

The page you were looking for no longer exists

I was anti religious for many years having grown up in the south and been around so many hypocritical Christians. In college I took some philosophy class on morality and was forced to ask myself if there were such a thing as right and wrong and if so what was the source of this morality. Atheists, agnostics, and secular people in general often answer the question by appealing to some sort of real life karma. If you do bad things society is worsened and in the end you are affected negatively by this. I.e. it's in your best interest to not harm others. Let's pose this question differently for the sake of this argument. If there you were in a situation where you could rob a person for a few million dollars, and in the process kill them, would you? If we use the secular self interest argument then we immediately see that the slight negative impact, assuming the police don't catch you, of killing this person is far outweighed by the huge positive of the money. Your children will have their college paid for, etc, etc. Therefore, the karma like self interest does not hold as a means of morality. Once forced to answer this for myself, a once atheist, I came to realize that there needs to be a source for morality and I see no secular source for it. The only other option is a truly dog eat dog world, and this I do not believe in. This began my spiritual voyage.

del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • crazy4thislife said on May 13, 2006....
    How is your voyage going?
  • stark said on May 18, 2006....
    it sputters along :(
  • SOLDIERCIPSWIFE said on May 18, 2006....
    Welcome to the path of discovery :) Sounds like you are learning so much of who you are...My mom use to say- Picture Jesus on your shoulder when you are faced with a decision. Im not sure how to say what I mean but I will try...that always made me stop and think-account for my actions-feel safe when faced with fear. When I forgot he was there- I got into trouble and I felt so bad and so guilty knowing he was there the whole time and I just forgot. You sound like an incredible human being. I think I will continue to read you and follow you in your voyage. I am so sure I could learn some things from you!

Comment on "morality"

morality religion philosophy (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)
Comment Anonymously

NOW HERE'S A QUESTION...
Kennedy get banned from communion for his stance on abortion......
It's okay if you disagree ... but when leaving a comment, please dont be a childish douche and resort to namecalling and insults....
JUST A LITTLE BIT OF HISTORY...
TAKING PRISONERS...