I will take your advice and start talking. Or atleast try. You've put it beautifully.. the commitment is already there.. its just a word.. right.. thanks Luce!!
I don't know how old you are, but you seem to be very young. Taking the fact that you are together for 5 years with the BF makes me assume that you - hopefully - some where around your early twenties?
Let me tell you, marriage is NOT JUST A LITTLE WORD. Marriage is a very serious thing that is being over used and abused these days. People get married way too fast, and for all the wrong reasons, and today's economy and life style does not support the original purpose of what marriage used to be.
Think about it this way: Why do you need to get married? Today you can live together and even become legal life partners, having most of the common bebefits of a marriage (if you lived together for over 5 years and split up, you can go to the court to solve out the financial "who gets what" situation too). So why get married? Well, I believe that you should get married once you really plan to start a family. When you are ready to have kids, and engage in the responsibilites that come for a life time once you become a mom. As a single mom of over 7 years I've learned that having kids is what will change your life, and not that piece of paper that makes you legally married. Therefore, before you are having kids you should make sure you have finished school and achived some kind of a financial security. You should have a stable job along with your partner, and the two of you should be able to live by the 70/30 rule - 70% of the total household income should be enough for your monthly living, including bills, food, clothing, traveling and entertainment, while 30% should be set apart in savings (15% general for your futura kids, 15% for your retirement). Of course, this is an ideal picture drawn by financial advisers, and it is very hard to live by, but if you can at least say, that you both have a decent job, pay the bills and put a little bit aside, you are close enough. You should be able to stay at home with your children for at least a couple of months after giving birth, OR have a clear understanding with your partner about how to deal with the change in your lives. Having a baby, or babies is a huge change of life style, and the first couple of months are the most important for both mother and baby. You should make sure that you and your partner have similar goals for your lives, and have a similar idea of how to achieve them. These goals shoul include the both of you, because if one of you is just helping the other to get a better career, or whatever it is you go for, than it'll create an emptiness in the furute, which is a common reason for divorces today. It mostly happenes to women, who support their husbands by being a good wife, a good mom, while forgeting about what they wanted to do with their lives.
See, there is nothing wrong with getting married, as long as there are no children involved. But once there are kids, a divorce is effecting their lives the most, which is the real responsibility of the parents. Today every third couple ends up divorcing in an avarage 5-8 years.
I truely believe that you are rightfully feeling disturbed by the fact that your dad got into your private life like that. These things should be serious matters, and there should be no pressure on you to start talking about it. It is your life, it is your decision and I salute you for taking it serious enough to keep it aside untill it is really time.
I sense that the reason you and your BF don't talk about it is because the both of you know, you are not ready. Once you'll feel you might be ready for a step like that, you should start talking about the factors mentioned above before even saying that M word. Talk about your future together, about your plans, about your feelings in regards with children, and raising children. Many of the marriages break due to the couple's disagreement on how to raise their kids, how to act around them, and how to live as their parents. So make sure the two of you see eye to eye on matters like that before you even talk about that M word.
About your dad's comment I would recommend you to talk - but not to your BF, but to your dad. I think you should tell him how wierd he made you feel by even suggesting that you should make that move in your life. Tell him that these things are your private life, and pressure from the people you love will only create unhealthy decision making. Tell him that you do not feel comfortable by him dropping words at you like that, and ask him to allow you to open up about these things on your time, when it comes naturally.
I think if you'd even mention this to your BF it'd make him feel that same pressure you felt when your dad said what he said. But if you really feel like telling him about it, only because he is your best friend and you need to talk about your feelings this situation elevated, than just talk about it objectively and avoid start talking about the idea of marriage in general. Just tell him about it as an akward situation, and keep that as the subject of your conversation without letting it turn into a marriage talk. If he loves you, he should be able to listen to you and understand your feelings without thinking you are trying to suggest something you don't.
Forgive my long comment - I am a talker too :-)
ZsuzsiO: Thanks for the advice.. I think you are right and I do take it seriously.. I don't particularly mind my dad's comment.. I think it was meant in a very light hearted tone.. but it sure took me by surprise! I do know I'm not ready for that step for a few years yet until I'm settled in my career.. I'm just finishing my studies now.. and my dad is very career oriented for me too so I think he knows theres still a few years too.. I guess I'll just be waiting till I feel the time is right. Thanks for the long comment though.. I apprciate the thought you put in for me. :-)
trav: I did of telling him and seeing his reaction.. but more for fun than anything else. I believe that when the time is right, we will make a decision and it will be for the best. Though I'm no rush at all ofcourse. I'll wait a while before getting to that. I like things being uncomplicated for now, you know? Although I'm quite certain he is 'the one'. Naive.. I know!! But you can't control the butterflies.. can ya.. :-)
hottipsforyou: My family or father is not typical of anything. They would never make arrangements for me. I think you have some misconecptions about the urban India. And I am not at all headed to the USA. I don't know why you would assume that. And I've only been with one guy for the last five years.. actually he is the only guy I've ever been with. And god forbid if it ever falls through, my father will trust my judgement and would never judge me negetively.. I can assure you words like 'whore' or embarrasement would not be associated with me.
I don't know guys, I think that these cultural things really depend on each person and the family he/she lives in. Most countries that had practiced the arrange marriage and other cultural behaviour have now moved on iwth the exception of some extreme muslim countries.
However, these arranged marriages are still exists in these countries - I know since I live on one of those (country, not marriage). Only they are not as common as they used to be. In my country it is strictly among the religious community and the rest of us think it is extremely primitive. Apologies to whoever might read and get afended my my words, but my point is that even if it exists in a country, it does not mean that everybody lives by it or even agrees with it.
However, I did not know you were from India, and even I might have put my words in a more careful way in order to avoid to affend you, if I knew your background. I am glad to read that it is not the case, and that you do have a healthy outlook on life. I have a feeling that you have a wonderful relationship with your dad and the rest of your family as well, which is something to admire these days.
You should write a blog about this trip to that other country, and tell us all about it! I am interested!
I don't understand hottips4u at all. Why would want to put people into boxes like that based on .. what? The counry they are from? C'mon, now! If some one tells you something different from what you believe than just try to give them the benefit of doubt, and go with it.
The respect and suppoort of our parents is a big issue for any girl in any country regardless to cultural background. I understand that in India there are extreme cases and the majority you can see on the streets might let you assume it applies to all. But it doesn't have to. There are modern families in today's Indian society, and I personally know some people from India who can be living prove of that.
I was born in East Europe, and now live in Israel. None of the above discribed by you applies in my birth country, and other than what I mentioned about arranged marriages, not in Israel either. However, I cannot imagine a situation in which a girl wouldn't long for her parents approval and support.
However, from what I read up here, it seems like diabolicdame and her dad have a helathy father-daughter relationship, in which she can decide when and to whom to marry. Of course, we would only know any different if she'd decide to go for a man out of her race - but she doesn't, so why bother talking about that?
trav: Traditions hold true in some places and in others they are left behind in the past. It depend on your education, your family background, where you grow up etc.. you are right in saying that most people are keeping what they like and leaving the rest behind. For me.. I've grown up in a very secure and free environment.. in a very cosmopolitan city.. so I've always had all options to me.. I think that matters as well..
ZsuzsiO: Things like traditional marriages still exist ofcourse.. but a s you said it happens amongst some people and not at all amongst others.. its a matter of your environment and family. And you're right that its sompletely individual. Things in India.. or many other places.. are in a spectrum.. and while there are extremes.. there is a lot in the middle as well. I don't need anybody to give me the benefit of doubt though.. I'm not here to convince anyone of anything.. if they cna't see outside a stereotype then its their loss really. Thanks for all the good things you said and I'll surely blog about my trip when it happens! :-)
hottips4u: I don't quite understand what you are trying to say. Lose my dad? That is not possible. You don't lose family. And if you think a father is just someone who gives you money then thats a shame. I can tell you that is not my view at all. I love my father and he trusts me and is proud of who I am. My 'fucking' is nobodys's business. Least of all yours. I don't write about sex so that is not open for you to comment on.
About the race thing.. I met a boy in high school five years ago and fell madly in love with him and we're still going good. So the thing is.. I don't care about which race I can date and have never given a thought. There is one guy in this world that I want and thats it. But just so you know.. there are no restrictions on me as to who I marry or when. That is my decision alone and my parents trust me with it. If my bf had happened to be of some other race that would have been fine with my family but he's not.. so I don't see the point in giving it any thought.
Also if you think that all kids in India are tossed in the street or thrown into the sex trade.. I am sorry you have such a narrow mindset. You might have visited India but you saw a very small part of it.. and I've lived here for 21 years so I should know! And I don't care much if you respect indian women or not. You seem to know little of India or Indians and I will not waste my time telling you any more about it. I can see its rather futile and you can continue believing and writing whatever you wish.
Oh and by the way.. I'm not getting an education so I can leave India and family behind. I intend very much to come back. I'm getting an educaiton to get a qualification and to get an international perspective on my study. I love both my country and my family fiercely.. and I'm rather proud of both.
I would appreciate it if in the future.. if you have any questions to ask.. you please do it in a repectful and positive way. I will not allow negetivity towards me.. my country.. or my family on my blog. Thank you.
trav: I tried to take your advice and not reply to the negetive comments.. but I had to answer the questions once. I will not reply to any negetivity in the future though.
wishy: You understood exactly what I was saying.. thank you! hehe.. I do think it is a bit exciting that my dad has sort of given me his approval and yes I did freak out! lol.. you're totally right and it is about adjusting to this new set of dreams and reality. As far as stereotypes go.. I do not believe in them and they count for zilch as far I'm concerned! Thanks again.. :-)
skald: Thanks for the ((((hug)))).. I do think that it will make things easier.. and I like the idea of tellin my bf in person.. well atleast I know I don't have to worry about convincing my dad of it in the future!! :-)
Ohh its annoying I swear it is... so who's this then? ((sigh)) my partner... ((sigh))
Actually when we decided to get married it was the right time, we fell into it. He actually proposed old fashioned, I accepted and we married for ourselves at the right time.
You two will know what to do and how to approach this, there will always be people who will ask you when, assume you have made plans... just do whats right for you both..
btw hows your study going?
He proposed old fashoined.. awww!! :-)
Studies are going great Luce.. they have to.. its my main purpose of life right now. Although I am home for the holidays right now and having fun here.. ahh nothing can replace your mum's cooking.. or catfights with your sister! :-)
And I'm missing people on the site too.. I guess they get busy.. I did too for a while.. but yea I miss them nonetheless.
The more I read the more confindent I feel about you and your BF. You seem to be a smart and charmy girl, and a girl like you could only be in love with a boy, who can understand her. I think you should mention the whole thing with your dad and see where it'll go from there - I have a feeling that nothing bad can come out of that.
travelr712 I am so jelous of you! O a;ways dreamed of being asked in some extremely romantic way - instead our marriage was based on ice cold facts: I already had his baby and he wanted to study in the States and make sure his son will not be separated from him. So we flew to Cyprus to get around the whole Rabbinate (there are absolutely no court based marriages in Israel, only religious ones, and they take a long time to get ready to), and have it all done in a weekend. We were taken to the court house straight from the air port, so I got married in my sweat pants whit no make up, no nothing...... Didn't even have a nice ring to show up with. At the time I didn't care about these things, cause I thought they don't matter. But I keep longging for the white dress and the big rock on my finger, and the weddign with the belly dancer and the chair dance...... I was offered to get married several times after the divorce - by men who hoped to gain a pretty and young wife by giving her a green card. I wanted none of that and decided to move back to Israel.
After 7 years of being a single mom it is getting harder and harder to find a good guy I really want to be married to. My expectations are just getting higher and higher while I am getting older and thougher. If anything I should lower those expectations so some one would at least have a chance..... I don't know, I am just waiting for that feeling, when I know, that paper does not even matter. Than I want him to go out of his way just so he can do something out of this world romantic, so I can say "yes".......