uniquely-ironic's tags:
For the past 2 1/2 weeks I've been following the South Beach Diet.  I've tried to use a less regimented change in diet to lose a few pounds but I'm an all or nothing personality when it comes to food.  The problem being that I have no impulse control and easily fall into temptation in the forms of chocolate, pizza, mexican, ...........  it goes on and on.
 
So, in an attempt to lose some weight and not let down my coworkers on this biggest loser contest I buckled down for the diet.  I hate the first two weeks.  It's always the hardest.  I don't always manage to follow the details either.  (non-fat milk becomes 2% etc.)  I hate having to turn down chips and other glorious junk food.
 
I think it's working.  I feel like I've lost some weight.  I think my clothes are fitting a little bit looser. But I'm not really sure I've lost as much as I should have.  It's like I'm at a sticking point early on in the diet.  That point is well shy of my projected ideal weight.
 
So where does the scale come in?  Lemme tell you.  I know you're not supposed to step on the scale every day, but I'm compulsive.  I also know that if the scale goes back up that I'll feel bad enough to work harder on saying no to goodies or watch my portions better.  So for the past couple of weeks the scale has been messing with my head.
 
I saw small amounts dropping off the first few days.  Then, on a day that I was particularly bad and had one of the "avoid these foods" items I went down a larger amount than usual.  Huh?!
 
I didn't assume that I could get away with my little slip again.  I kept to the diet and the next day I had gained more than I had lost the day before.  Huh?!!
 
I'm technically off the strict first stage that's designed to help reset your insulin and help you decrease cravings.  I am "allowed" to add in small amounts of those things that I was supposed to avoid the first two weeks.  I'm too paranoid to do it.
 
The scale has been on a mission to destroy my confidence in the diet.  Up one day, down the other, some days it stays the same.  It has left me with the feeling that if I go back to my usual eating habits I might implode.  On days I feel thinner it says I'm heavier, on days I feel like I may have put on a pound or two it says I've gone down 3.  I'm so confused.
 
The only good thing about this diet is that I intellectually know that I'm eating healthier.  Whether or not my body wants to cooperate is another matter.  The scale and I are gonna have a "comin' to Jesus" soon if it doesn't start toeing the line!!!
 
 
 


del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • kruuyai said on Aug 21, 2008....
    hey, good luck with the diet, uniquely.  Have you ever tried the Blood Type Diet?  I tried it for health reasons... didn't want to lose weight, but even though I was eating like a pig, I couldn't pick up any poundage.  There are different guidelines for each blood type.  You can even get the info online at www.dadamo.com   Hope that's not too much like advertising... hee hee
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 21, 2008....
    Kru - I actually bought and read the book.  It isn't all that dissimilar to the South Beach for my blood type.  I choose South Beach over it because it had more choices for foods.  I did recognize that their recommendations on activity type are more dead on.
  • vacantmind said on Aug 21, 2008....

    Well, if you are anything like me not only do have to follow the diet but, you have to look at the amount of sodium you are really taking in. I have a tendency to hold alot of water when I am dieting. My scale does the same thing, over time I lose weight but that up and down gets me every time.

    I won't be stepping on the scale anytime soon though.

  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 21, 2008....

    vacant - water weight did cross my mind.  I don't think I eat an excessive amount of sodium, but I am susceptible to water weight gain.  I know around my period that I get all bloaty.  I don't want to take a diarhetic so I guess I need to cut back on salty things a little more.

     

    And no, you need not worry about stupid scales for the next few months!!!

  • vacantmind said on Aug 21, 2008....
    I didn't think I ate too many things with large amounts of sodium either until I added up my daily count. Pop..even diet is horrible for water gain.  I swell with water around my period as well. So, just keep an eye on your sodium and drink lots of water to flush your system.
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 21, 2008....
    vacant - I will, and short of making myself miserable I'll try to cut back further.  thanks for the reminder.
  • nytquill17 said on Aug 21, 2008....
    Fluctuations like that are totally normal from day to dayl.  It can be related to water intake, sodium intake, how much you sweat, have you moved your bowels, is your period coming on...

    But there are some pitfalls to watch for too.  If you are overrestricting yourself, either on calories or certain key nutrients, your body thinks there is a famine on.  Then the days that you do eat more than usual your body will stash away the extra calories for "safekeeping," thinking that food might be hard to come by in the future and you better build a backup while the getting is still good.  It's the same concept with water.  If you're chronically dehydrated, then your body hangs on to all the water it gets because it doesn't "trust" you to give it any more!  That's why when you first start drinking your 8 cups a day if you haven't been, you will bloat for a few days.  If you steadily drink enough water, your body adjusts to the new intake levels, decides you will be safe without your backup storage, and lets you pee out all the retained water.

    You also gain weight when you build muscle.  When you use a muscle, your body starts to store more glycogen (the type of sugar used as muscle fuel) directly IN the muscle for easy access, preparing itself for more of this increased use in the future.  Sort of like the little baggie of Cheerios that you probably carried everywhere when your kids were young ;)  Where you gain weight when you build muscle is not so much the muscle tissue, though it does weigh more than fat, but in the glycogen.  It takes 3 water molecules to make a glycogen molecule, IIRC.  And water, by volume, is pretty heavy.   So you might see a weight fluctuation depending on how hard you exerted yourself the day before, how much glycogen your body feels it needs to store in your muscles.

    If you have a way to make a graph - I use an online tracker that will show me my data points as far back as I want it to go, but you can use one of the basic Office softwares (I forget which one does it now) or plain old pen and paper - that will help you a lot, because you will get to see the overall curve of your weight change instead of being zoomed in on "weight yesterday vs. weight today."  There have been times I thought I wasn't losing ANY weight only to look at my graph and realize it was curving gently down, just not enough to see day-to-day.
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 21, 2008....
    nytquill - all good points.  For the past 6 weeks I have been drinking water to hydrate using the equation of body weight divided in half equals number of ounces of water to intake daily.  I have not adjusted it down to cover what I've already lost reasoning (perhaps wrongly) that if it's excess it will go through.
     
    I am aware that muscle is heavier, so I have been less alarmed.  I may have put on a tiny bit of muscle with the added exersize.  I did not know that about the glycogen, so maybe that has come into play.
     
    I'm less sure about my exact calorie count.  When I have an "indulgent" moment, it is usually an extra slice of bread or 1 ounce of chocolate.  Probably not enough to make a huge difference in the amount of daily calories.  I don't think I'm on an extremely low calorie count though as I eat three meals a day and two snacks to keep my blood sugar stable.  I don't measure my food though so who knows.
  • silver_phoenix said on Aug 21, 2008....
    hi u-i~ i don't even step on the scale when i'm working on weight loss! maybe a lil less face time with the scale is what ya need =)
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 21, 2008....
    silver - I tried that route.  Apparently I'm the type of personality that needs a constant reminder.  I have a really big penchant for living in denial, hence the weight gain.
  • secretlife said on Aug 21, 2008....
    i'm with silver phoenix on the scale thing- 
    i'm a once a month scale person- 
    God i hate the scale!
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 21, 2008....
    SL - If I get within 5 pounds of my ideal weight, I'll jump on the once a month band wagon.
  • queenparanoia said on Aug 21, 2008....

    throw that weighing scales out the door!!! lol!!!

    i tried south beach once and yeah i did lose some weight but emotionally i wasn't happy cuz i love food...

    anyway, i hope you continue yours!!! ;-)

  • dailyachesandpains said on Aug 21, 2008....
     
    Unique:  Scales are NOT allowed around me at any time.  I am a recovering anorexic and always recovering. 
     
    With my back problems, my doctor had me go to pool therapy.  Let me tell you something...my doctors treating my disease were NOT happy as I just kept dropping the lbs. and they didn't know until I was WELL underweight and in for a check-up.   I (Anorexic side of my brain) was LOVING it...even though it didn't do much for my back.  It was under an hour and three days a week.  There was a PT working with me and giving me pool exercises to help with my back.  I passed out when I got home from every pool therapy appointment from exhaustion and possibly malnutrition on top of it. 
     
    Do you know if there are any indoor pools near you that have trainers?  The pool I was in was obviously indoors (New England weather) and it was only 5 feet at it's deepest. 
     
    I hope this might help you in the exercise department if that's what you're looking for?  I HATE exercise, and I always have, but this was fun and quick!
     
    Daily
     
     
     
     
  • skald said on Aug 22, 2008....
    Good luck with your diet. I feel the best thing to do is eat less and move more. And stepping on the scale each day. I don't see that it can harm. I think not stepping on the scale is dangerous. hahha. 
  • CreativeWoman said on Aug 22, 2008....
    I think your scales and mine must be distant relatives.  I step on mine everyday too with the same type of trends going on that you experience.  I also find it a little frustrating.

    Congratulations on your success.

    CW
  • CayenneMan said on Aug 22, 2008....
      uniquely-ironic the more you concentrate on reaching your goal the harder it will be to accomplish. Maybe if you try taking ginger root and 1000 mg of vitamin C in powder form (capsules are available but are'nt as effective) 1 half hour after your first meal of the day (breakfast ?) you would find it to be easy and you would'nt have to give up on pizza?  
  • RollingC said on Aug 22, 2008....
    Go down to South Africa and live the nomadic lifestyle of the Swahili.  Running after their cattle, protecting them from Lions, drinking cow blood for breakfast  and doing their jumping tribal dance whenever they have a get together or tribal occasion.
    I've never done it but I saw a cool documentary on it and it's guaranteed to make you lose weight (you'll wind up being as skinny as they are).....heh....

    Either that or just go into eating half rations for a period of time and eat whatever you normally eat but only half rations.

    :^)
    Rc
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 22, 2008....
    queenie - I'm afraid it's my love of food that got me to this place.  I love food, but I need to negotiate some kind of truce between it and my body shape.
     
    Daily - I'd love to do pool exersize, but I have an allergy to chlorine.  (can you believe that?!!)  I do try to get to the gym for exersize on the joint friendliest machines.
     
    skald - yes, NOT stepping on the scale got me where I am.  I agree that eating less and moving more is the key.
     
    CW - psychotic scales!!  I'm trying to not take the numbers personally.
     
    CM - ginger root and powdered vitamin C.  Hmmm, I'll give it a try.  BTW, I haven't totally given up pizza, but it has become a once a month treat in small portions.
     
    RC - the running and jumping part of that doesn't sound that bad, but I'll take a pass on the blood stuff.  It might just be easier to eat smaller portions of better foods for awhile.
  • catch22 said on Aug 22, 2008....

    Fruits,vegies,whey protein mix,*JUICE PLUS,the weight flys off and stays off. Vitamins A,B,C,D,E are important as well. Pure spring water is great.

     

  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 22, 2008....
    catch - what is *JUICE PLUS?  I am familiar with whey protein and drink shakes now and then when breakfast isn't likely.  I do need to get a good multivitamin.
  • CayenneMan said on Aug 22, 2008....

      Uniquely-ironic, forget about the ginger root and vitamin C , consider going along with RollingC's suggestion. I just saw a spaghetti noodle run by me, it was an old friend of mine said he just got back from South Africa and he was living with the Swahili for a bit. RollingC's right it must be the way to go. My freind (tiny) used to always ask me to go ice fishing with him. I took him up it one day. As we approached the ice . . . people were screaming and fighting to get off the ice ( at the time tiny weighed 450 +)  , it was the damndest thing uniquely-ironic I just could'nt figure it out.  After we walked about a half a mile on the frozen lake to the good fish'n spots I asked my friend tiny what were those noises we had heard. He said pay no mind to it the ice is just shifting. I told tiny I forgot my chewing gum and ran like hell back to my truck.    Wow just like they say it all comes back.  If I ask my friend tiny to go ice fishing with now, he may turn me down?      Wow this sucks . . . I regret starting this article I gotta piss like a race horse  . . .  

  • catch22 said on Aug 22, 2008....
    C-MAN says to forget vitamin C. Don't listen to that! Google *JUICE PLUS and you will be amazed at what you discover. Also..mega doses of C (4 1000 mg a day) will do wonders for your health. This is very safe!
  • CayenneMan said on Aug 22, 2008....
        
     
                                                  Pop goes the weasel ! 
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 22, 2008....
    catch - I'll look into it.  My health is less an issue than my weight.  I know that sounds contradictory, but it isn't.  I am 100% prescription drug free, but I do need to lose some weight.
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 22, 2008....
    CM - Did you take your meds today?  You're in quite a mood ;)
  • dailyachesandpains said on Aug 22, 2008....
    Unique:  You know it's funny you mentioned that allergy, I was having problems with the chlorine.  I left there with a throat issue each day.  You know my weight issues were extreme enough to think if my throat closed on me, at least I'd be thin in a casket.  Such a horrible thought, I know. 
     
    Try the ocean or a lake??  Eawie on the lake...wicked willies!  You'd need to get the water weights and pool noodles to do some of the exercises.
     
    Daily
  • CayenneMan said on Aug 22, 2008....
       Uniquely-ironic the only meds I ever remember taking in my live was a penicilline shot I was forced to take bacause of my parents. I stepped on a rusty nail at the location of a tree fort I had been working on. But thanks for the shove I can get carried away at times. It assists me in knowing my limits. I cut my grass yesterday in just under four hours.Today I felt good and decided to spend some time with Jack . . . Jack Daniels that is. My wife is looking at me like I've done something wrong . . . maybe she's right ?
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 22, 2008....
    daily - I'll have to do some research and see if there are any beaches or rivers that are swimable during the warm weather.  Tiny coffin?!!  Don't you dare!!!
     
    CM - Nah!! I didn't understand that "Jack" was responsible for your silly mood.  Give your wife a wicked sexy wink.
  • silverwhisper said on Aug 24, 2008....
    u-i, that scale is gonna have to go in the closet, if you ask me!

    so i see the south beach diet is a low-carb one. i've had good success with the atkins diet, which is strictly about insulin/sugar levels.

    if you don't mind my asking, what's your target?

    ed
  • uniquely-ironic said on Aug 24, 2008....
    SW - as part of the office "biggest loser" contest our fitness coach weighed us using a specialized scale.  According to that scale my ideal weight would be 140 lbs for my height (5'6")  I'd be happy to be within 5 pounds of that.

Comment on "Sadistic Scale"


(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)

How often you replace your contact lens comes down to a couple factors. The most important being the health of your eyes. Some lenses are designed to last longer than others so follow the advice of your eye care provider....
Everyone desires to be a better person, yet that can seem to be an unattainable aspiration. Discover how you can start to consciously take steps towards that goal everyday......
For any fitness enthusiast, a good pair of athletic shoes is a must. From working out at the gym to jogging, from playing tennis and other sports to simply taking brisk walks, athletic shoes go a long way in protecting your feet and overall body post...
The Energy and Resources InstituteTERISmall Industries D...
So you want to be a counseling student, or perhaps you are a counseling student, looking for some funny stories, or you want to counsel students.

Have you heard of the Mind Sparke Brain Fitness Pro? It is a computerized brain fitness program ...