hotaka's tags:

As you know, we bought a house in May. With a wedding, baby and new house this year so far people are scrambling to bestow us with gifts for one celebratory event or another. A good friend of mine stopped by one evening to give me a housewarming gift. It was a large flat package that I knew would be a frame of something. I wondered what he had chosen. Was it a painting or photograph? Was it maybe just a frame so that I could enlarge and display one of my own photos?

After he left I opened the wrap. It was a painting, a certified reprint apparently, of a painting by a well-known artist. I didn’t know who he was nor did I know he was well-known. The painting was of a couple floating in the sky and holding each other. There was a horse with Picasso-like eyes and L’arc de triumph. There was other stuff too and maybe it would not have been so weird had it not been for the big blotches of red that looked like raw meat. One part that looked like it could be the horse’s legs was all meat red as was the woman’s dress. Meat. Raw steak! I thought it was hideous. I told my wife and showed her a photo I took with the digital camera.

What should we do with it? If we invite him over he will like to see the painting up somewhere. No doubt it was expensive as a certified authentic print. I couldn’t just remove the print and use the frame for myself. I left it by my entrance for a couple of weeks. After seeing it everyday I got used to it - basically I got used to ignoring it. Our bedroom has an empty wall where it would fit perfectly. Perhaps we could hang it there. I asked my wife. She wasn’t thrilled but shrugged her shoulders and agreed we could try to put it there.

When it comes to giving gifts, especially clothes and art, it is really important to know what the receiver likes. Though you may have an interest in something there is no reason to assume that your friend or relative will like it. Being forced out of politeness and manners to accept a painting I don't care for and feeling obligated to hang on my wall something I would have just walked by in the store is uncomfortable. I want to receive gifts graciously and return the favour. But this puts me in a pickle.

My parents once gave my wife some clothes for Christmas. The clothes were nice enough but not her preferred style. She never wore them and my mother asked some time later if she ever wore those clothes. She took offence to not seeing my wife (girlfriend at the time) wearing those clothes. I don’t think you should expect anyone to gladly wear clothes you give them if you don’t even get their opinion before buying it.

del.icio.us Digg reddit StumbleUpon

Comments

  • secretlife said on Jul 19, 2008....
    it IS uncomfortable to get a piece of art as a gift.
    i'm sure you're friend thought it was great, but what if you bought him a painting for his house?  i mean who picks out art for someone else?
     
    i say this because i have, over the years gotten several prints as gifts.
    what i did hotaka was pack them away in a closet.
     
    the people that gave them to me never asked.  and if they had, i had an excuse already in mind that they didn't quite "go" with our current decor, so i was "saving" them for a time when we would redecorate.
     
    clothes are difficult to buy for any adult.  my mother still attempts it for us sometimes- although less and less as we get older.  i remember the first christmas after my sister-in-law and brother married and my mother tried to buy her a suit.  it was pretty funny - you could tell immediately that the style was not hers.  luckily my mother doesn't remove tags and staples the gift receipt to the tag so that anything can be returned. 
  • fearing said on Jul 19, 2008....
    Gift cards.  I love gift cards for this reason. 

    The painting sounds awful but I agree you should try to hang it somewhere so your friend won't be offended.  When I think of how this painting was obviously expensive like you said, the time it took your friend to get it for you, the thought into it and his excitement over giving it to you - I might not dislike it quite so much.  When you see it through the friendship you have, I bet it won't be ugly any longer. 


  • botoni said on Jul 19, 2008....
    Personally I have no ability to understand why people think that something they find wonderful is going to be given the same status by anyone else.  My motto in gift giving is that I must be absolutely sure it is something the recipient will like otherwise I go for consumables that I already know are their taste.
  • queenparanoia said on Jul 19, 2008....
    oh i know what you mean... that's why if i dont know the person well enough i go to "safe" gifts. like candles. etc... and etter yet money!!! or a gift certificate!!! =)
  • nytquill17 said on Jul 19, 2008....
    You know what I don't get?  This whole thing of the giver "expecting" to see their gift worn, displayed, etc. by the recipient.  I mean that's basically demanding that the other person like your gift!  That's where all the awkwardness in bad gift-giving really comes from - not the gift itself but the fact that there are expectations on the recipient.  And think about it...if you give someone a gift and then expect something from them, doesn't that undermine the whole point of it being a GIFT?

    It's like saying (and I mean no offense to your mother or your friend here) "I am insecure about the gift I chose for you.  It is now your duty to reassure me that I have good taste."

    I mean, we all want to know that our gifts are appreciated, but we have to accept that sometimes they won't be (though not appreciating a gift is not the same thing as being ingrateful that the gift was given - one should always be grateful for the consideration!).  The whole point of giving someone a gift is that it becomes theirs and we let it go.
  • Fallyn said on Jul 19, 2008....
    put it in a safe deposit box and if the friend asks about it tell him it was too valuable to just hang on the wall so you are saving it for when you have more "security"

    save it for the baby's college fund or something.
  • Lucytorial said on Jul 19, 2008....
    Okay I am terrible with gifts that I don't like... admitedly I gift them to someone else that I know will appreciate them... some gifts I have had for years and then Bammooo the perfect person presents themselves and I gift away....
  • uniquely-ironic said on Jul 20, 2008....
    Art is such a highly personal item.  I'm always less than thrilled when someone buys a print for me, though I smile, thank them and even hang it somewhere for awhile if it's from someone who might see it.  That picture sounds like something that neither of you really likes, it's too bad you don't have a hallway spot or some place where it would be unobtrusive to hang it for a few months.
     
    For this same reason I tend to buy generic gifts for people I don't know well.  I am never offended if they return them and buy something they need or like.
  • CreativeWoman said on Jul 20, 2008....
    In ten years, I've never, ever once gotten a gift from my in-laws that fits my tastes even though they make a big deal about writing things down on a "wish" list.  I had to use a mailbox and wall decoration that I absolutely hated because they were gifts from them.  I smiled inwardly the day my husband accidentally backed over that mailbox with the tractor.  :-)  It was about that time that I replaced the things on the wall too.

    It's a very sticky situation to be sure. 

    CW
  • Fallyn said on Jul 20, 2008....
    CW...... my ex's mother picked out my every day dishes for me as a "gift" *frown*
    considering we had none at the time we couldn't very well refuse them......
    needless to say we had TOTALLY different tastes.
  • CreativeWoman said on Jul 21, 2008....
    Fallyn,
    That would be awful.  How did it make you feel when you used them over and over?

    CW
  • hotaka said on Jul 22, 2008....
    secret, I lived with a girl many years ago who had no qualms about heading straight to the store to exchange a gift she didn't like. I am a little better at putting the item somewhere and then forgetting about it or ignoring it or getting used to it. I said we would hang the painting in the bedroom because that is where we have the space and where the colours might best go. But it is also where my friend is least likely to see it as in Japan it is not normal to invite visiting guests to your bedroom unless... you know. But he's not that kind of friend!

    As for my wife's gift of clothes, my mother went through great pains to find a store with Asian staff who were small and slim so as to find something that Asians wore and would fit my wife. She asked a Vietnamese girl who would no doubt have looked nice in those clothes. But a late 20s Japanese woman and an early 20s Vietnamese woman would not suprisingly have different taste. Mom made an excellent effort however and she knew it too. That's why it was a kind of offense not to see her gift appreciated and worn.
  • hotaka said on Jul 22, 2008....
    fearing, you made an excellent point about the gift coming from a friend. That's partly the reason it's hard not to try to do something with it. Were it solely up to me I would hang it and get used to it. But I have my wife's opinion to consider too. If she can accept it then we'll hang it.

    botoni, my best friend and I are always burning CDs of songs we like and sending them to each other. ut one thing I have noticed is that we always "like" each other's music but we usually don't "love" it. I listen to the CDs from him once and probably he does the same with mine. Then they get shelved and forgotten. At least they don't take up space. Otherwise I find food makes the best gift. You really have to know what the receiver of the gift likes before buying clothes, though T-shirts are usually safe between guys.

    queenP, yes, gift certificates or money are often more appropriate.

    nytquill, you made some excellent points too. I usually try to use very practical gifts that are not going to be in the way if they are not appreciated. I would never buy anyone a painting unless I was damn sure they wanted it (I found a miniture replica of a painting my mother always spoke about that she loved and bought it for her). If the person is genuinely glad to receive the gift then I am really happy. If not then it was my poor choice and I can't expect that person to like it. Though so far I have been good at choosing gifts, I think.

    Very considerate of you to add the "no offense" remark. Your thoughtfulness is much appreciated though I would have understood and not taken offense.

    Fallyn, well, it's not out of the plastic wrap yet! You may have a point about my kid's college fund. I knew a very good painter from Washington State once whose works shot up in value when he rode his bike off a cliff in the Cascades and died. Not that I hope this painter will die but you never know.

    Lucy, your comment reminds of a joke on... maybe it was Johnny Carson and the Late Show: "There is only one fruit cake in the world and everyone just keeps giving to someone else."


  • hotaka said on Jul 22, 2008....
    UI, had the painting been half the size we could have dealt with it much more easily. But it's 3x4' or so and we hardly have a wall suitable for it except in the bedrooms and one in the living room where I planned to put shelves with family photos. A small painting would have been better. The house warming gift was thoughtful but perhaps flowers and a fruit basket would have been better, wouldn't you think?

    CW, your husband "accidently" backed over it? It wasn't because he knew you hated it and perhaps (for once) did something to please you? Oh, you reminded me of a wooden carving my parents sent us from Fiji. It is rather ugly and to make things worse they had our names engraved in it, my wife's name spelled incorrectly!

    Fallyn, oh, I wouldn't want dishes either unless they were plain white. What you have in your home is a reflection of your personality. If you have to serve guests with dorky dishes someone else likes it must make you feel like apologizing when the plates come out.

Comment on "The Gift of Giving"

observations (Click to add tags below)

(Separate tags using commas, for example: New York, dating, vegetarian)
Comment Anonymously

Subscribe to the SoulCast Newsletter To Receive the Best Uncensored Blogs About Love, Sex, Relationships, God, Politics, and More.


Ever wonder what people really think and how they really live?

Read about the real lives of regular people like you whose powerful moving blogs will make you smile, cry, emotional, and warm inside.

Your FREE SoulCast newsletter is just moments away. Receive your first feel-good blog by entering your email address below.

First Name:
Your Email:


You can unsubscribe at any time with one click. We NEVER sell or share your email address with anyone. Period. close